Gregor Kollmorgen today posted photos at The New Liturgical Movement, (as that blog is wont to do), of an abbatial blessing at Rein Abbey (Cistercian) in Austria. The photos are quite nice; it looks to have been a splendid, joyous occasion both for the abbey and the Church.
The comments at the end of the article, however, are very discouraging. Kollmorgen wrote:
Yes, there are altar girls and Communion in the hand. While this is regrettable, let’s not make this the topic of discussion again on this occasion; otherwise I would have to disable comments on this post.
It seems that we have two issues:
- “altar girls”
- Ministering Holy Communion in the hand
In all of my reading about the liturgy I have never found the Church refer to “altar girls.” In our liturgy there are, however, “altar servers,” the gender of which is not specified. Yes, I have heard all of the arguments for male-only altar serving, but I don’t buy them. The denial of any baptized Christian a chance to serve at the Altar of God is nothing more than misogyny dressed up as holiness. Altar servers ≠ ordained ministers. Period.
Regarding the reception of Holy Communion in the hand, this is a perfectly licit practice. Really, that ought to end the discussion right there. If it’s licit, it isn’t regrettable. Personally, perhaps, but that wasn’t the point of the jibe.
Sacred liturgy is important. Therefore, it is of absolute importance to practice charity and prudence when we discuss it. Let’s leave aside the personal chauvinism in favor of a community-oriented approach to the liturgy which is, after all, the work of the people. Not male people: all people.
We must reform ourselves before we can reform the liturgy. Let us begin with charity.
Pax et bonum.